Grinch Thumbprint Cookies With Heart-Shaped Jam Centers (Easy Christmas Recipe)

Sharing is caring!

These green thumbprint cookies are a fun Christmas dessert made with bright green almond-flavored cookie dough and sweet, heart-shaped jam centers. Inspired by the Grinch and his heart growing three sizes, these festive treats are perfect for Christmas parties, holiday trays, and family movie nights.

Each buttery cookie has a tiny red heart of fruit preserves in the center. The contrast between the green dough and glossy filling makes these little treats especially cute on a holiday serving platter.

We love Grinch-themed recipes and crafts, and you can find a list of 100+ Party Food Recipes here.

Easy Grinch thumbprint cookies for Christmas

Table of Contents

Grinch Thumbprint Cookies With Heart-Shaped Jam Centers

This cookie recipe uses simple baking ingredients, including softened butter, sugar, flour, eggs, almond extract, and green coloring. Shape the dough into balls, chill it to limit spreading, and bake before adding the jam filling.

The batch makes approximately 36 pieces, making it a great choice for Christmas gatherings or holiday exchanges.

For another festive treat, try our green Rice Krispies Treats, which feature bright green cereal squares with candy faces.

Finished green Grinch thumbprint cookies with jam hearts on a festive Christmas serving plate

Easy Grinch Thumbprint Recipe for Christmas

Traditional thumbprint cookies usually have a small round indentation filled with jam or chocolate. These green holiday treats put a Christmas twist on that familiar cookie with heart-shaped centers.

The hearts represent the moment in Dr. Seuss’s classic Christmas story when the character discovers the true meaning of Christmas.

Almond extract flavors the dough, while the fruit preserves provide the filling. Unlike treats decorated with frosting or candy hearts, these have their heart shapes formed directly in the dough.

Why You’ll Love This Cookie Recipe

  • The bright green dough makes each piece stand out on a Christmas dessert tray.
  • Heart-shaped jam centers give them a recognizable story-inspired design.
  • The almond-flavored dough pairs with the sweet fruit preserves.
  • No special cookie cutter is required.
  • One batch makes approximately 36 pieces.
  • With an adult nearby, kids can shape the dough balls and make the little hearts.
  • You can prepare a batch in advance and keep it frozen until you need it.

Ingredients for Christmas Thumbprint Cookies

You’ll need eight basic ingredients to make these festive holiday treats.

Ingredients for Grinch thumbprint cookies, including butter, sugar, flour, eggs, preserves, and green food coloring

Ingredients

  • ¾ cup unsalted butter, softened
  • ¾ cup granulated sugar
  • 2 teaspoons almond extract
  • 1 large egg
  • 1 large egg yolk
  • Green food coloring, as needed
  • 2½ cups all-purpose flour
  • ¼ cup strawberry or raspberry preserves

Butter

Softened butter helps create the dough’s tender texture.

Use butter that is soft enough to cream with sugar but has not started to melt.

Sugar

Sugar adds sweetness when you cream the butter and sugar together at the beginning of the recipe.

Almond Extract

Almond extract gives these buttery treats their distinctive flavor.

The original recipe uses two teaspoons, so almond is a noticeable part of the finished batch.

Whole Egg and Extra Yolk

Together, the egg and extra yolk give the mixture enough structure to come together. Work both into the creamy butter-sugar mixture before adding the dry ingredients.

Green Coloring

Food coloring gives the treats their bright, story-inspired appearance. Add enough to reach your preferred green color. The exact amount depends on the type and concentration of the coloring.

All-Purpose Flour

Flour gives each piece enough structure to hold its shape and keep its heart-shaped center. Check your measurements so extra flour does not dry out the dough.

Fruit Preserves

The preserves create glossy, ruby-red centers. Both fruit options work well for this recipe.

Use a thick preserve that spoons neatly into the baked heart-shaped wells.

Kitchen Tools You’ll Need

Gather these baking tools before beginning:

  • Stand mixer with paddle attachment
  • Measuring cups and spoons
  • Baking sheets
  • Parchment paper
  • Small spoon or rounded measuring spoon
  • Cooling rack
  • Refrigerator or freezer
  • Small spoon for filling the hearts

A small cookie scoop can also help you divide the dough into similarly sized portions.

How to Make Heart-Shaped Christmas Cookies

Start by mixing the green dough, shaping it into balls, creating heart-shaped impressions, and baking in two stages.

Follow the instructions below for the recipe shown in the photographs.

Step 1: Cream the Butter and Sugar

Place ¾ cup softened unsalted butter and ¾ cup granulated sugar into the bowl of a stand mixer.

Beat until the mixture is evenly creamy.

Stop the mixer occasionally and scrape the mixture from the sides into the center of the bowl.

Softened butter and sugar in a stand mixer bowl for Christmas thumbprint cookie dough

Step 2: Add the Eggs and Almond Extract

Add 1 whole egg, 1 egg yolk, and 2 teaspoons almond extract. Keep mixing just until the eggs and almond extract blend into the butter mixture.

The egg yolk adds richness, while the almond extract gives the dough its flavor.

Eggs added to creamed butter and sugar for Grinch cookie dough

Step 3: Add Color

Add the food coloring to the mixture. Begin with a small amount and mix until the color is evenly distributed.

Add more coloring if needed to create a bright green shade. A concentrated gel-based color can produce a vibrant shade without adding as much moisture as liquid food coloring.

Green food coloring added to almond-flavored cookie dough

Step 4: Mix in the Flour

Gradually add the flour, starting with about half, and mix on low speed. Once combined, add the remaining flour.

Mix until just combined and a thick dough forms. Use the paddle attachment rather than a wire whisk for this stage. As the dough thickens, the paddle handles it more easily than a whisk.

Stop mixing as soon as you no longer see patches of dry flour.

Flour added to bright green Grinch cookie dough in a mixing bowl

Step 5: Finish Mixing the Green Dough

Check that the flour and coloring are evenly incorporated into the mixture. The finished dough should be thick enough to hold its shape when rolled into balls.

If necessary, scrape down the bowl and mix briefly to incorporate any remaining dry flour.

Thick green cookie dough mixed and ready for shaping

Step 6: Roll the Dough Into Balls

Line each cookie sheet with parchment paper. Divide the dough into portions about the size of ping-pong balls.

Round each portion with your palms to form a smooth ball. Set the balls on the lined trays with roughly two inches of space between each one.

The batch yields approximately 36 pieces, depending on their size.

Green Grinch cookie dough rolled into balls on a parchment-lined baking sheet

Step 7: Create the Heart-Shaped Indentations

Use your thumb or a teaspoon with a rounded back to shape a heart in the center of the cookie dough ball.

For a heart-shaped center, make two small rounded impressions near the top and bring them together toward a point at the bottom.

Gently press so the indentation is deep enough to hold jam without going through the bottom of the dough.

Repeat with the remaining portions.

Heart-shaped indentations pressed into green thumbprint cookies

Step 8: Chill the Shaped Dough

Refrigerate the shaped pieces, or place them in the freezer, for approximately 30 minutes before baking.

The cooling period helps prevent spreading and keeps the heart-shaped details intact during baking.

As the dough chills, set your oven to 375°F so it is ready for baking.

Step 9: Bake for 10 Minutes

Place the chilled pieces into the preheated oven. Bake for 10 minutes.

By then, the cookies will have started to firm up, but they still need a second bake. Use oven mitts to take out the trays and set them on a heat-safe surface.

Step 10: Fill the Heart Centers With Jam

While the baked pieces are still on the baking sheets, spoon strawberry or raspberry preserves into each heart-shaped center.

Use a small amount of red jam so the filling remains inside the heart rather than overflowing onto the green edges.

Aim for a clear red heart framed by a neat border of green dough.

Grinch thumbprint cookies with glossy heart-shaped preserves centers on a cooling rack

Step 11: Bake for 5 More Minutes

Return the trays to the oven for approximately five additional minutes. Across both stages, the cookies spend approximately 15 minutes in the oven.

Avoid letting the edges brown, since this can change their bright green appearance. Take out the trays and leave the baked cookies undisturbed as they begin to cool.

Step 12: Cool and Serve

Let the baked treats cool until the jam centers have set enough for handling. Transfer them carefully to a cooling rack, and let them cool completely.

Arrange the finished heart-shaped cookies on a Christmas serving platter.

How to Make Heart-Shaped Thumbprints

The heart-shaped filling is what makes these sweets different from classic thumbprint cookies. You don’t need a special heart cookie cutter.

Instead, use a finger or a small rounded spoon to form the impression directly in the dough.

Use Two Small Impressions

Press an indent in the center of one side of each dough ball. Make a second mark beside it, angling the two impressions slightly toward each other.

Together, they should form the two rounded sides of a heart.

Shape the Heart’s Tip

Bring the two rounded marks together at their base to give the heart a tapered tip. Leave enough dough beneath the design to keep the jam from leaking through.

Keep the Edges Thick Enough

Leave a border of green dough around the heart. This helps hold the preserves in place during the final baking stage.

Chill Before Baking

Once you’ve formed the heart impressions, chill the shaped pieces as directed.

That cooling period keeps the small heart details more defined during baking.

Close-up of two Grinch cookies with chocolate heart centers on a white plate.

Tips for Perfect Grinch Cookies

A few simple techniques can help these jam-centered treats turn out well.

Use Softened Butter, Not Melted Butter

Butter that is too warm can affect how the dough behaves.

Choose butter that yields to gentle pressure but isn’t oily or runny.

Avoid Packing the Flour

An overly generous measure can leave the mixture crumbly instead of easy to roll. Fill the measuring cup loosely with flour, then sweep the excess off the top.

Choose a Vibrant Green

Green gel food coloring is a useful option for a vibrant Christmas batch. Add the color gradually until you reach your desired shade.

Keep Portions Similar in Size

Use a cookie scoop or divide the dough evenly so everything bakes at a similar rate.

Don’t Skip Chilling

The recipe calls for 30 minutes of chilling before baking. Cold dough is less likely to flatten, which helps keep the little hearts visible.

Use Thick Fruit Preserves

A thick fruit preserve is easier to place inside the heart-shaped center than a thin, runny fruit sauce.

Avoid Overbaking

Check the edges during the last few minutes. You want the dough to bake through without developing significant brown edges.

Why Do My Thumbprint Cookies Spread?

A few common baking issues can cause the shaped dough to flatten. If the butter is overly soft or melted, the dough may lose its shape more easily.

Skipping the chilling step can also cause the shaped portions to flatten during baking.

To help prevent spreading, follow the 30-minute chilling step and avoid placing warm dough onto hot baking sheets.

Wait until the oven reaches the specified temperature before sliding the trays inside.

Why Did My Heart Indentations Disappear?

The dough may have spread or puffed during baking. Make the heart-shaped impressions deep enough to hold the filling without cutting through the bottom.

The chilling step can also help preserve their shape. If the centers puff substantially during the first 10 minutes, you can carefully redefine the impressions with the back of a small spoon while the treats are hot, before adding the preserves.

Use caution because the baking sheets and baked dough will be hot.

Can You Use Different Jam Fillings?

You can try other fruit fillings, although this version originally uses thick red preserves.

Strawberry Preserves

Strawberry preserves provide a sweet flavor and a familiar fruit filling.

Raspberry Preserves

Raspberry preserves offer a slightly tart contrast to the almond-flavored dough.

Cherry Preserves

Cherry preserves are another possible variation if you prefer a different fruit flavor. For the strongest visual contrast, choose a red or deep pink filling.

Other fillings may behave differently during baking, so the original fruit preserves are the best starting point.

Can Kids Help Make These Christmas Cookies?

Yes! This is a fun holiday baking activity for families. Younger children can help roll the green dough into balls once the ingredients are mixed.

Older children can practice forming heart shapes with their fingers or a small spoon. Adults should handle the oven, hot baking sheets, and the jam-filling step when the treats are hot.

You can also pair the activity with a reading of the classic Christmas story and talk about the character’s heart growing three sizes.

For a simple companion activity, try our printable Christmas name game.

How to Store These Heart Cookies

The recipe directions recommend storing cookies in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to three days. Allow them to cool completely before storing.

If stacking the pieces, place parchment paper between layers to help protect the jam centers.

Can You Freeze These Thumbprint Treats?

Yes. According to the recipe, you can freeze this batch for up to three months.

Place fully cooled cookies in an airtight, freezer-safe container, separating layers with parchment paper. Thaw in the refrigerator before serving.

The appearance and texture of the jam may change slightly after freezing.

Can You Make Them Ahead of Time?

Yes. Bake the treats a day or two before your Christmas gathering and refrigerate them in an airtight container.

For the freshest presentation, arrange them on a serving platter shortly before your party.

Heart-Shaped Thumbprint Cookies for a Christmas Party

These holiday sweets are a cute addition to a story-themed dessert table.

Their bright green color and glossy heart-shaped centers make them easy to recognize as story-inspired treats.

Serve them with other holiday desserts and festive snacks.

For a larger Grinchmas celebration, pair them with our Nutter Butter treats, which feature green candy-coated sweets decorated with expressive yellow eyes.

You can also try our peanut butter snowball cookies, a no-bake treat decorated with small red hearts.

For a savory option, our themed charcuterie board is another festive party food idea.

Planning games for your guests? Add our free Grinchmas party games for a complete Christmas celebration.

More Grinch Recipes and Activities

If you enjoyed these heart-shaped holiday treats, explore more festive recipes and activities from 24 Hour Family.

Plate of green Grinch thumbprint cookies with chocolate heart centers arranged in a flower pattern.

Make These Heart-Shaped Holiday Cookies for Christmas

These festive thumbprint treats are a fun way to bring a familiar Christmas story to your holiday spread.

The green almond-flavored dough and sweet heart-shaped jam centers make them a festive addition to Christmas parties, cookie trays, and family baking traditions.

With a simple shaping technique and no special cutter required, they’re also a fun recipe to make with children.

Save this recipe for your next Christmas celebration, and enjoy sharing a little holiday sweetness!

What makes these heart-shaped thumbprint cookies special

They’re green Christmas cookies with heart-shaped centers filled with fruit preserves.
The design is inspired by the character’s heart growing three sizes in the Christmas story.

Do I need a heart-shaped cookie cutter?

No. Use your pinky finger or the back of a small rounded spoon to press the heart shape directly into the dough.

What flavor are these treats?

The dough is flavored with almond extract, and the centers contain fruit preserves.

Why are they green?

Their bright color comes from the food dye mixed into the dough.

When do you add the jam?

Bake for 10 minutes, carefully fill the heart-shaped centers with preserves, and return to the oven for approximately five more minutes.

What temperature do you bake these thumbprint cookies?

Bake them at 375°F.

How long do they take to bake?

The total baking time is about 15 minutes: an initial 10-minute bake, then another 5 minutes after filling.

Do they need to be chilled?

Yes. The recipe calls for approximately 30 minutes of chilling before baking to help reduce spreading.

Can I use raspberry jam instead of strawberry?

Yes. The original recipe allows either fruit preserve.

How many pieces does this recipe make?

The recipe makes approximately 36 pieces, depending on the size of the dough portions.

How long do they last?

Store them in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to three days, as recommended by the recipe.

Can you freeze these thumbprint cookies?

Yes. You can freeze them in an airtight container for up to three months.

Grinch thumbprint cookies recipe

Grinch Thumbprint Cookies

Yield: 36 cookies
Prep Time: 10 minutes
Cook Time: 15 minutes
Chill Time: 30 minutes
Total Time: 55 minutes

Bright green almond-flavored Christmas thumbprint cookies with heart-shaped strawberry or raspberry preserve centers. A fun Grinch-inspired dessert for Christmas parties and cookie trays.

No Ratings

Ingredients

  • ¾ cup unsalted butter, softened
  • ¾ cup granulated sugar
  • 2 teaspoons almond extract
  • 1 large egg
  • 1 large egg yolk
  • Green food coloring, as needed
  • 2½ cups all-purpose flour
  • ¼ cup strawberry or raspberry preserves

Instructions

  1. In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, cream the softened butter and sugar until smooth.
  2. Add the egg, egg yolk, almond extract, and green food coloring. Mix until combined.
  3. Add approximately half of the flour and mix on low speed. Add the remaining flour and continue mixing until a thick dough forms.
  4. Line baking sheets with parchment paper.
  5. Portion the dough into approximately ping-pong-ball-sized pieces and roll into smooth balls.
  6. Arrange the dough balls on the prepared baking sheets, leaving about two inches between cookies.
  7. Use your pinky finger or the back of a rounded spoon to create heart-shaped indentations in the centers.
  8. Refrigerate or freeze the shaped cookies for approximately 30 minutes to help reduce spreading.
  9. Preheat the oven to 375°F.
  10. Bake the cookies for 10 minutes.
  11. Carefully remove the baking sheets from the oven and spoon strawberry or raspberry preserves into the heart-shaped centers.
  12. Return the cookies to the oven for approximately five more minutes. Do not allow the cookies to brown.
  13. Remove from the oven and allow the cookies to cool completely before storing or serving.

Notes

  • Use the paddle attachment rather than a wire whisk when mixing the thick cookie dough.
  • Chill the shaped cookies before baking to help preserve their shape.
  • Use a small spoon to fill the hearts without overflowing.
  • Strawberry and raspberry preserves are both suitable.
  • Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to three days.
  • Freeze for up to three months in a suitable airtight container.
  • The 55-minute total does not include cooling time.

Nutrition Information:
Yield: 36 Serving Size: 1
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 92Total Fat: 4gSaturated Fat: 3gUnsaturated Fat: 2gCholesterol: 20mgSodium: 5mgCarbohydrates: 12gFiber: 0gSugar: 5gProtein: 1g

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *